SYTYCD: 4 of 20 voted off

23 Jun

Tonight’s episode of So You Think You Can Dance was so disheartening it’s forced me out of my hiatus from this blog. So, last week, the judges couldn’t decide what boy to kick off the show, and so they decided to keep everyone. Yay! But that meant this week, four people had to go home. Boo! For some reason, instead of making it a bottom four couples, they kept it at bottom three, meaning that of six dancers in the bottom, only two could stay. Very bad idea: At least with eight dancers in there, and half going and half staying, there are more options. As it was, as soon as I saw what girls were in the bottom (Ryan, Iveta, Missy), I knew that Ryan would be staying. And that sucks. Now, don’t get me wrong, Ryan’s a good dancer. They’re all good dancers. But Iveta is the ONLY ballroom dancer this season. THE ONLY ONE. And, in my opinion anyway, she’s a better ballroom dancer than Ryan is a contemporary dancer. Then, there were the boys: Nick, Wadi, and Ricky. My heart was torn on this one, because Nick is a tap dancer, which means he gets my automatic allegiance, but I also love Wadi. So of course, they kept the one I didn’t care much about, Ricky. Yes, his solo was great. But Nick was a tap dancer, and Wadi was hip hop (or free runner). Which means a) my hopes for a tap routine are dashed unless Jess sticks around until they break up the couples and then gets a tap routine, which would be a mixed blessing since I do not like him, and b) they got rid of three non-contemporary dancers, making this crop of dancers even less diverse than it already was. They have this problem pretty much every season, but this season feels REALLY loaded with contemporary dancers and contemporized versions of other dances. Not cool. And speaking of those dances, what’s with having each choreographer do two dances per show? Where did all the choreographers go? I don’t understand. Widen your pool, show! This situation is not good at all! Another issue: the judging. Now, I don’t like watching the judges lay into any of the dancers. It’s very sad. But I also don’t want them to say basically the same thing about every single dance and dancer, going on about how wonderful they are the choreographer is and this season is etc. etc. (with the exception of maybe one dancer a night, like what happened with poor Wadi last night). It’s only the second week. There should be some actual critique going on. Now, I am not a professional dancer, nor am I particularly qualified in any other way to be judging dancing, but they can’t ALL be flawless. Which leads into the other problem: these random guest judges. I have nothing against Megan Mullally or Debbie Allen. But they might as well have been a recording of “that was great!” played over and over again. If they can’t add anything of substance, especially when Nigel and Mary aren’t really critiquing, then bring back the choreographers-as-judges. Sigh. I had such high hopes for this season. They obviously aren’t fully gone yet, since it’s only the second week. There’s still definitely time for improvement. But things are just off, and it’s making me sad. Fix it Nigel! You fixed the stage and the top 20 issue and turned down the volume of the audience finally, now fix this too!

PS are the video editors over there INCREDIBLY fast, or did they already know who was going home? The fact that they didn’t have, for example, a Missy block of footage and then an Iveta block of footage, but instead mixed Missy footage with Iveta footage, makes me suspicious. Hmmm…


One Response to “SYTYCD: 4 of 20 voted off”

  1. Vicky June 23, 2011 at 10:27 pm #

    I could not have agreed more.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: